My Stepdad Raised Me Since I Was Four—Then on His Deathbed He Whispered, “I’ve Lied to You Your Entire Life”

about,” I said.

Caroline didn’t answer right away. She opened a drawer beside the stove and set it in front of me — a small collection of metal cookie cutters. A heart. A flower. A little rabbit. An apple. And one small, battered star.

I stopped breathing. It was identical to the one Frank had used every Sunday of my life.

“Where did you get that?”

“It was Frank’s.”

“No — his is at my house. I have it.”

“He had two, dear,” Caroline said gently.

Beneath the cutters was a photograph.